Magdalene Cruthers Is Going To Hell
Page 66
“The performing. The séances and such. You don’t have to worry about them anymore.”
“What do you mean?” She had quite deftly avoided any mention of her previous life, and had absolutely no desire to discuss her history of being a charlatan with the man she was quietly in love with.
Theo huffed out a laugh. “Just what I said. You don’t have to pretend to be speaking to the departed or however you put it.”
She pulled away. She knew her face had grown white; she could feel the blood leaving it. “You’re calling me a liar?”
“I—no?” Theo waved his hand around. “I’m telling you that I understand, to a point, how relieved you must be to no longer be living your former life as a show woman. Should I not?”
Maggie stared. “I never told you about that.”
“You didn’t have to.” His color was rising. “I mean, I always knew. I knew you were … well, I don’t want to say faking it, but I know a performance when I see one.” He paused. “You were very good, Maggie.”
He knew. The thought thrummed through her, pounding in time with her heartbeat. He had always known. And knowing what she was—a fraud, a liar, a predator of the vulnerable—he had held her, defended her, trusted her with his daughter and his time and his body.
He knew.
“Maggie?”
The worst part—significant, in this situation simply riddled with terrible things—was how calm he was, as if her soul had not just left her body. His gaze was intent, a notch in his furrowed brow, and she felt a tremor of rage climb her chest until it exploded out of her mouth.
“Why the fuck didn’t you say something?” Her voice wasn’t her own; it was some primal, hissing thing emerging from an unmined place deep inside her. She shoved him, surprising them both, and he bumped against the wall. “For months, Theo, I have been disintegrating over this. I don’t know how you could just stand there, day after day, and not tell me that you knew!”
His face had arranged itself into an expression of utter bewilderment. He opened his mouth twice, trying to form words, before shaking his head. “How was I supposed to know that it was tormenting you? I thought we had established that mind-reading is not possible.”
A slightly hysterical laugh leapt out of Maggie, and she gestured around wildly at … what? An invisible audience, witness to her indignation? “Theo, I don’t—I can’t—” She leaned against the kitchen table, slumping her shoulders. “Theo, I don’t think I can do this.”
He stilled. “Do what?”
“Whatever this is. This friendship. Our friendship.” She tapped her fingers against the wood of the table, trying to find a rhythm to cling to. “I can’t look you in the eye. You know too much. Oh, my God.” She knew this was panic taking over, yanking the reins from her hands, but she didn’t know how to yank them back.
“Magdalene, I have always known.” She flinched at the frustration in his voice. “I adore you, but you are not as good of a liar as you seem to think.”
“Not with you,” she shot back. “Only you. I can be anything anyone wants. I can tell them anything that they want to hear and make them believe it, but not you.”
Every touch they had exchanged had been her; she could not recall one instance where he had taken the initiative, had crowded her or startled her. So, it was with some alarm she registered him striding towards her, eyes dark, and it was with a shocking, delicious surge of hunger that she reached for him just before his body collided into hers, his callused hands grabbing her hips and drawing them to his as he pressed his face into her neck. Maggie ran her fingers into his hair, yanking it as he bit into the skin of her throat, puffing soft moans against her.
She knew, vaguely, somewhere in her lust-muffled mind, that the shape of their friendship was about to change dramatically and irreparably. The thought turned to ash as Theo’s mouth touched hers, and suddenly her existence narrowed to his tongue stroking hers, his fingers dancing along the sides of her waist. She was a tsunami wave crashing, or a volcano erupting— some natural, elemental force about to flood into the Earth and ruin lives.
Hers, specifically.
Theo, unaware of her sluggish, existential dread, simply pressed her further into the kitchen table. She was nearly horizontal now, and the edge of the table was digging into her back. She pulled her head back, gasping, and Theo ran his tongue along her jaw. “Lou and the baby …” She faded into a moan when he sucked at the thin, delicate skin under her ear.
“Janey took them to market,” he murmured, switching his attention to the thudding pulse near her collarbone. He licked it. “They’ll be gone for hours.”
“Theo,” she managed. He paused, lifting his head to look at her, and she nearly shivered at the hunger on his face. “Take me to bed.”
It wasn’t really their first time, considering how he had used his mouth on her before, but it felt like something rare and precious to Maggie. He was well-acquainted with her breasts, had learned quickly what she liked—his hands plumping them, his mouth sucking them hard until they were red and almost sore, her nipples small, hard points in the cool evening air. They were shining now, wet with him, and she could hardly stand to look. His dark head was slowly making its way down, pressing warm kisses as it passed: a lick on her ribs, a nibble of the soft skin of her belly. When he reached his destination, he glanced up for silent permission, which she granted with a small thrust of her hips. He kept his eyes on hers for a moment, almost grave, before settling on his stomach and wrapping his arm around her thighs to keep her in place.
Maggie threw her head back against the pillow, moaning low in her throat as Theo pressed his tongue to her clitoris, unmoving. He lay there for a moment, and she felt the warm air of his releasing breath run along her abdomen. Tentatively, she brought her hands down and buried them in his hair, twining curls around her fingers, and he groaned so hard that she felt it reverberate throughout her core. Any pretense of pleasant torture was gone now, and Theo hiked her leg over his shoulder, running his nose along her wetness until she sighed. She jerked when he sucked on her clitoris gently, her thighs starting to shake before he placed a firm hand on her stomach, pressing down. He didn’t look up from his task, but the meaning was clear: don’t move. But she had to. She tried to stop her body from writhing under this onslaught, but then he slid two fingers into her, and the exquisite fullness was overwhelming, and she was falling from some great height, rushing downward. She felt utterly laid out, more naked than she had ever been, silently asking for what she needed, silently permitting him to do whatever he wanted to her body.
It was raw and wild, this primal offering of herself, and she desperately, desperately wanted to tell him what she was carrying around in her chest. She wanted him to know he was wanted, and adored, and cherished, and that she would lay herself out in this pagan sacrifice any time he wanted. At that moment, with Theo’s mouth touching her, and her fingers tangled in his hair, she would have given up a pound of flesh for him to understand how much she loved him. It was suffocating, not telling him. Her sentimental thoughts were interrupted when Theo crooked those fingers inside her, pressing into some part of her she had not been aware of, and Maggie nearly screamed.
“God,” she breathed, pushing her hips up into his mouth. “Do that again.” Theo obliged, teasing that unknown, electrified place inside her, and she lit on fire. The pillow beneath her head was damp with sweat and she let go of any vague idea of pride. She would die for this pleasure, and she didn’t care who knew it. She’d yell it from rooftops, a bell in her hand: Theo Barrow is very good with his hands; tell all you know. He hummed into her, his tongue increasing its speed, lapping at her, and she knew the end was about to begin. She was huffing out breaths, barely holding on, and he latched onto her, suckling steadily. Maggie twitched, and moaned, and hit the ground, shattering. On and on it went; the seizing, the clamping and waves, her body trying to pull him in. Theo muttered something unintelligible, withdrawing from her abruptly, and she looked down at him. Her chest rose and fell rapidly despite the languor settling into her, and she smiled lazily when Theo undid his trousers. He shed his shirt next, kicking everything aside and dropping to the bed, crawling up until he caged her, gazing down at her with a look verging on anger.
“Theo?” she lifted a hand to his face, tracing his lips with a gentle fingertip. His expression didn’t change, and alarm crept in, warring with her warm satisfaction.
“Shush,” he said, hoarse. “I need to memorize how you look right now.” He lowered his head, running his nose along her jawline. “Sated and soft and warm beneath me.”