AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Magdalene Cruthers Is Going To Hell

Page 58

by Ali Lockhart

Lou’s mouth twisted. “He leaned quite heavily on caring about our immortal souls. Made it very clear that he knew we were all going to burn forever in the fiery pits of Hell, and would we consider being rebaptized to save ourselves?”

“Isn’t that what pastors do?” Maggie asked. “Offer their services in exchange for the satisfaction of knowing they’ll get to lecture you in heaven for all eternity?”

“He cited a few specific instances that would make me particularly vulnerable to Satan’s embrace.”

Maggie’s mind reeled. “I can hardly picture you committing murder, Lou.” Not entirely true.

Lou was quiet for a moment, picking at some grass next to the quilt. Maggie had never seen her absently fiddle with her hands before, and a mild sense of foreboding rose in her. “Lou?”

“It was hypocritical.” Lou lifted her chin. “Sam and I, when I was maybe fifteen and he was seventeen, we—” She set her jaw and stared hard at Maggie. “It was just experimenting. We didn’t know what we were doing. And it wasn’t forced, or anything like that. It was shared … liberties. Nothing bad. Nothing too good, either,” she added, glum.

Ah. Maggie nodded. “I’ve shared some liberties myself.” A truce, two women guarding each other’s long-gone virtue.

Lou exhaled. “Well, Sam changed his mind about it later. Said I had tempted him as a test and our… intimacy had been nothing but his own moral failing. That I should be ashamed at how easily I fell.”

Maggie recoiled. “That’s despicable.”

“He told me if I didn’t regularly join services, he would tell my parents that I—” she cut herself off, returning her gaze to the small mass of obliterated grass on her lap. “Well, that he would tell my parents.”

“What did you do?” Not attend services, that much was sure.

“I told them myself.”

Maggie drew her knees up, resting her chin on them, looking at Lou. Proud, stubborn Lou, who knew she wasn’t easy to love but refused to cut herself into smaller pieces.

“They didn’t speak to me for weeks. But I didn’t have to go to services.” A smile.

“Did you tell your brothers?”

“I told Theo. He asked if I had been forced into anything and when I said no, he never mentioned it again. I think he didn’t want me to feel worse.” Of course he didn’t.

“Is Sam still so …” Repugnant? Vile? Unforgiveable? “… diligent?”

“No.” Lou stretched her arms over her head, wincing. “He seems to have given up. He’s never discussed anything of substance with me since, and Theo’s kept him at a bit of a distance.”

“I had no idea he was so dreadful.” Maggie sniffed; the air was thick with pollen and her nose was stuffed.

“He has his moments,” Lou shoved some cheese into her mouth. “I don’t think he’s ever cared for anything the way he cares for those children at the home, and that can’t count for nothing.” She stood, wobbly. “Good lord. That wine’s gone to my head. We should head back.”

“Yes, let’s tackle delicate stitching now that we’re drunk.”

Their lunch by the river had sunk into Maggie’s mind—Lou’s bravery, Sam’s cruelty, Theo’s… well, Theo. She hadn’t seen him in four days, and his absence was beginning to fester like an open wound in her chest. They had left things unsteady just as she was finding her sea legs, and the thought that he was upset with her fluttered around her head, an irritant she couldn’t soothe. She felt too awkward to go to the butcher shop, and at any rate Lou would just bring anything they needed, and she very well couldn’t drop by the house unannounced. She considered hiding in the bushes near his home to wait for him to leave before she realized that she was going insane.

She also realized, with some surprise at herself, that she very much wanted to hold Emmy. Maybe tickle her stomach and make her laugh. She missed her tiny smile punctuated with sharp teeth, her delighted giggling and finger-points. She missed her nonstop nonsensical babbling with the odd real word thrown in. She missed her.

“You’re being quiet,” Lou commented, not looking up from the boning she was adding to a bodice.

Maggie decided, for once, to take the path of least resistance. “I need to speak to your brother.”

“Oh?”

“We had a bit of an argument, and I want to apologize.”

“You must have been awful,” Lou said pleasantly. “Why not visit him at the shop?”

Hadn’t she been listening to Maggie’s thoughts? “It feels strange to do it in public.”

“So go to the house.”