AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Magdalene Cruthers Is Going To Hell

Page 56

by Ali Lockhart

Eighteen

Theo was obsessed. He didn’t bother denying it to himself; he was as helpless as a starving man before a feast. Every bit of his mind craved Maggie: she was sly, and amusing, and harsh. Every inch of his body craved her: she was soft, and generous, and her mouth … Well, it was the center of his fascination, that mouth. Whether it was casually spewing insolence or buttoned tightly against questions, he found it enthralling. He wanted to coax her, draw her out like a viper from its den. He wanted to tell her everything and ask her everything and offer up his heart on a blood-soaked platter.

He would have been alarmed, but he had felt this once before.

He had made a tactical error when he had seen her three nights earlier; clearly the subject of Tom and Bridgers was more forbidden than he had anticipated. The sheer terror she had displayed when she realized Theo knew they were lovers had been startling, but he should have known better: the list of secrets she thought she was keeping was growing rather long, and she always bolted like a scared rabbit when they were even hinted at. He’d asked Lou if she’d ever broached this particular topic with Maggie, and his sister had responded with a thin-lipped, “That’s none of your concern.”

The women in his life were walking question marks.

It was a relief, in a way, that it was out in the open now (well, as open as something could be between just two people), but he knew she was still upset and so had avoided her since that night. Pointless, really. All he thought about was her, even now in this uncomfortable meeting with his brothers and the Engelsens, the family of the German man Jake had encountered while touring the old Ryne street grocer. Isaac, the son, was a reserved man who quietly observed the conversation while his father, Josef, was slightly more animated. The office in the butcher shop was small, not built to contain five people, but Jake had procured more chairs and the group was situated comfortably, if cozily.

“Profits would not be split?” Josef asked, nervously holding the mug of tea David had poured. Isaac’s sat on the desk, untouched, and he fiddled with a loose button on his jacket.

“Oh, no, certainly not.” David shook his head, resting his forearms on the other side of the desk. His relaxation was a stark contrast to the discomfort radiating off the two newcomers. “Just the space, and the rent. And of course, if one of us is using more space, we can adjust accordingly. We want everything to be equitable.”

“When Jacob and I first met,” Isaac said, shifting in his chair, “he said that your shop has been here for many years.” The Barrows all nodded in confirmation. “Why the interest in moving now? Surely there is security in staying in one spot.”

Theo cleared his throat. “Certainly, security is an accurate term. However, we think that we have the capability to offer the community even more than we currently do once we are not restricted by the limitations of our current space.” He was pleased with how professional he sounded. “Additionally, we believe that your contribution to Roslyn would be both welcome and successful.”

Josef’s smile was wry. “It is not many Americans who welcome immigrants into their towns, Mr. Barrow.” His accent was heavy, but Theo found it warm and rich. “We had some family in the city, but my wife’s health suffers from the smog.” He shook his head. “The doctor recommended we go further north for her lungs, and we had to leave our neighborhood.”

“I’m sorry,” David said, sympathetically. “It couldn’t have been easy to leave something so familiar, particularly if you feel like an outsider now.”

Isaac smiled for the first time since sitting down. “You’re kind.”

“The village is kind.” Theo was beginning to wonder if everyone thought that they were some sort of small-minded backwoods swamp people. “We’re rather a crucible of different people, really. Our local papermill owner is the son of enslaved people who were freed after the war, and the feed store is owned by a nice Italian couple.” He felt his color rise as the Engelsens looked at him curiously. “Not that … I mean, that makes it sound like I’m keeping a tally. I just mean we’re quite diverse, and you’re welcome here.”

An awkward silence followed while Jake sent Theo a bewildered look.

“Would the Barrow butcher shop be willing to sell us meats for ingredients?” Isaac looked up, bouncing his gaze between the three brothers.

David beamed. “At an industry discount, of course.”

The Engelsens looked at each other. “I must speak to my wife,” Josef said, standing from his chair. “I dare not make any decisions without her input.” He smiled. “But I think we are interested.”

“That’s wonderful news,” Jake said, leaning over the desk to shake the men’s hands. “Please, consult with your family and let us know. The brokers told us no one else has shown an interest in such a large space, so I don’t think we’re in any rush.”

The Engelsens left, and the brothers all dropped back into their chairs.

“Father is going to be very upset when he finds out,” Jake offered, putting his feet up onto the windowsill and settling his clasped hands over his stomach.

“Father is going to be very upset no matter what happens,” Theo responded. He let his head thunk gently against the wall behind him and closed his eyes. The idea of expanding was a relief, in an anxiety-inducing way, and only grew sweeter at the thought of how bothered his father would be.

Hell hath no fury like a father threatened, he thought, and smiled.

“I agree,” David said. “He walked away when he retired, and the shop belongs to us.”

Theo felt a niggle of guilt that Lou had not been present—she owned 25 percent of the shop, same as the rest of them—but she was busy at the haberdashery and had insisted that she trusted them. His guilt was replaced by jealousy. Lou wasn’t too nervous to be in Maggie’s presence right now. Lou was privy to her secrets. Lou wasn’t the one falling in love with the infernal, prickly woman.

Well, wasn’t Lou just as lucky as a leprechaun.

“I feel good about this,” he said, ignoring his own thoughts. “Improving the business and bringing in new blood.”

David stood, stretching his arms over his head and releasing an audible snap from the vicinity of his spine. “Mother would be livid if she knew we were going into business with a Jewish family.”

Jake grinned. “Proof it’s the right thing to do.”

Lou, who was already hardly what anyone could call predictable, surprised her even further by doing something she had never done over the course of their acquaintance: she proposed they take a break. If she knew that Maggie and Theo had had a disagreement, she kept it to herself, and Maggie was disinclined to drag anyone else into her own inability to conduct herself like a normal person, so she had kept silent on the matter.