Page 155

That’s the sentence that won’t leave me alone. Natalie’s mom is genuinely the woman who wounds her and genuinely the woman who raised her in the faith. Both, at the same time. And the gap between them isn’t proof of a lie. It’s just the shape of a broken person doing her best and failing and being loved anyway.

And once I can hold that about Natalie’s mother, I can’t stop it from spreading, back and back, to the place it’s been locked up my whole adult life.

Back to when I was seventeen. The woman I trusted most with my brand-new faith, worshiping on Wednesday, gossiping on Thursday. I’ve told that story to myself so many times, and every single time it has meant the same thing. It’s all fake. They’re all frauds. If the best of them is a liar, none of it’s safe, and the only smart move is to leave.

I sit on my bed and I look at that seventeen-year-old for the first time with the key in my hand, and I see what she couldn’t.

She was right that the woman was broken. She wasn’t wrong about the gap. What she got wrong, what wrecked ten years of her life, was what the gap meant.

Because here is the thing I could not do at seventeen, the thing I have not been able to do since, the thing that has kept me out of every warm room I ever wanted to sit in.

I couldn’t separate the people from God.

I took a broken woman’s failure and I hung it on Him. I decided that because His people were hypocrites, He must be a fraud too, that the whole thing was rotten from the stage down, and I walked away from a perfect God because imperfect people disappointed me. Which is, I understand now, sitting on my bed with one earring in, roughly the same as refusing to believe in the sun because somebody once gave me a bad sunburn.

The people were always going to fail me. Every one of them. Natalie, her mother, the woman in the parking lot, Ivy, Harper, Luke someday in some small way, me most of all. That was never the question. People are broken. All of them. All of us. That’s not the exception, it’s the whole human condition, it’s page one.

But I kept doing the math like their brokenness was evidence against God, when the entire point, the thing Pastor Jack has been saying since that first Sunday, is that their brokenness is exactly why we need Him. Grace isn’t for people who have it together. There are no people who have it together. Grace is the whole and only plan for a species that cannot stop letting each other down.

It’s not complicated.

I’ve spent my entire adult life certain that faith was a thing you had to be smart enough and careful enough and safe enough to earn, that the gap between who people are and who they say they are was a puzzle I had to solve before I could trust any of it.

It’s not a puzzle. It’s the simplest thing there is.

We are all broken. We all need grace. And a person looking fine on the outside isn’t always a liar. Sometimes she’s just a woman calling the thing that isn’t as though it were. Sometimes the front isn’t a fraud.

Sometimes it’s hope.

I don’t finish getting ready.

I slide off the edge of the bed and onto my knees on the floor of my apartment, in one earring, with fifteen minutes until a firefighter and his grandmother pull up to take me to play bingo, and I do a thing I have never once done alone, out loud, in this room. I’ve prayed in my head here a thousand times, careful and edited. I have never gotten on the floor and said it with my mouth.

I do now.

“God.” My voice sounds strange in the empty room. I keep going anyway. “I owe You an apology, and I owe one to a lot of Your people, and I don’t know how to do this, so I’m just going to do it badly.”

I take a deep breath.

“I judged Natalie. I sat next to her while she was brave and I called her a fraud in my heart. I’ve done that to almost everyone You’ve ever put in front of me. I took the worst thing broken people ever did to me and I made it Your fault, and I left You over it, and I stayed gone for ten years, and I told myself the whole time I was just being smart.”

A tear slides down my cheek.

“I wasn’t being smart. I was scared, and I was proud, and I was wrong about You. I’m sorry. I’m so sorry. You were the only one in the whole story who was never going to leave, and I treated You like the first one out the door.”

My face is wet. I let it be.

“I don’t have it all figured out. I probably never will. But I’m done requiring You to make sense before I’ll trust You. I’m just going to trust You.”

I kneel there a second longer in the quiet.

“And thank You for the wrong number,” I add, because it’s true and because I mean it more than almost anything. “Amen.”

When I get up off the floor, something’s different, and it’s not dramatic, and I keep waiting for it to be and it isn’t. There’s no lightning. The apartment looks the same. I put in the second earring.

But the splinter I’ve carried for seven weeks is gone, and under it, the older thing, the low mean hum I’ve carried for ten years, the one that says everyone leaves and nothing’s safe and I was always going to end up alone. It’s quiet. Not gone, maybe. But quiet in a way it has never once been, like a machine that ran in the background so long I stopped hearing it, finally switched off.

I look around my apartment. The candle four inches off center. The recipe box. The drawings on the fridge. A whole life I let people into, built on a foundation I spent a decade refusing to stand on.