Page 129

“No.”

It comes out of me hard and fast, and my head’s already going, too quick, before I’ve decided to move it.

“No. Never. Not that.” My head won’t stop shaking. “He was cruel. He hit, and he drank, and he made me hate the inside of my own skull. He was never that. It wasn’t that. I need you to hear me say it plainly, so you’re not carrying the wrong picture out of this room — it was not that.”

“Okay.” Something goes out of him on the breath. “Okay. I hear you. I’m sorry I asked. I had to know what—” He stops. “I had to know.”

“Now you do.” I make my voice the door again. “Now you know what’s actually in the box. That’s what you’d be signing for. Not the girl who hosts the dinner. The nights I won’t sleep. The way I’ll flinch when a man raises his voice in a room, even you, even though you never would. The part of me that’s always already half out of every door. You’d be choosing all of that, on purpose, for good. And I won’t let you, because you don’t know yet that you shouldn’t, and I have always known.”

And this is the part of the script I couldn’t write. Because it was never mine.

This is where he fights.

He doesn’t.

He stands in the middle of the warm room with his hands open at his sides and his whole face working, and he goes quiet.

I know this quiet. I’ve watched it come down on him before. Cash has a name for it. It’s the thing he does when he’s feeling the most, when it’s gone past the place his words live, when the captain takes the wheel and the captain’s only job is to keep the room from seeing the size of it. He goes still. He goes silent. He holds it in his body so it won’t spill on anyone else.

“I don’t—” he starts, and it dies in his throat. He tries again. “Sloane, I—” and that one dies too. I watch the want climb all the way to the surface and stop there, like a word he can see plain on a page and can’t make his mouth release, and I know that look, I’ve watched it cross his face over a textbook, the stranded helplessness of a thing that’s right there and won’t come out. Except this isn’t a page. This is the one sentence that would keep me. And he can’t find the shape of it, because no one ever once told him he was allowed to stand in a room and say I want this, it’s mine, don’t take it from me.

So the room just fills with his silence.

And I do the thing I came here to do, the worst thing, the thing I’m good at. I read his silence the way I need to read it. I let it mean what I need it to mean.

He isn’t fighting because he agrees. He’s seen the box now. He’s gone quiet because under the shock he knows I’m right, and somewhere in him the relief is already starting, the slow grateful understanding of the favor I’m doing him.

That’s what I tell myself. I’m very good at telling myself things. It’s the family trade.

And he doesn’t say it.

He doesn’t say I love you. He said it four days ago in his childhood bed, plain, into the dark, like he was naming the color of the sky. I said it back. Both of them are still in this room. His and mine, lying right where we set them down. He could pick mine up. He could hand it back to me right now and it would stop me cold, it would pull the whole stack down in a second, and he knows that, and I know he knows that.

He doesn’t do it.

He won’t use the one thing that would work. He won’t weaponize it. He just lets it lie there on the floor between us, true and useless, because using it to keep me would make it a thing he took instead of a thing he gave, and he won’t, not even now, not even to save it.

And that — the mercy of it, the unbearable Beau-shaped decency of it — is the thing that nearly finishes me, when every reason I brought in with me couldn’t.

He crosses the room. I should have known he would. He’s never once known what to do with his hands when he’s feeling the most, so they go where they always go, and he stops in front of me and lifts one and sets it against the side of my face. Careful. The way you hold a thing you’ve already lost. His thumb at my cheekbone. He doesn’t say anything. He just looks at me and holds my face in his big warm hand like it’s still his to hold.

And I don’t lean into it.

That’s the hardest thing I do all day. Harder than the speech, harder than the box, harder than the door. I keep my face exactly where it is and I do not turn it into his palm the way every cell I have is screaming to, because turning into it is a yes, and I came here to say no. I have spent twenty years learning how to hold still while the thing I want sits one inch away on the wrong side of a decision I already made.

He feels it. The not-leaning. I watch him feel it. His hand stays a moment longer, like it’s arguing on its own without him, and then he takes it back, slow, and something closes in his face that I don’t think opens again for a long time.

“Okay,” he says. Barely. “Okay.”

My eyes sting. The back of my throat does the thing it hasn’t done since I was small on a kitchen floor, the hot tight climbing thing, the body remembering a door it bricked up years ago. For one second I think it might actually happen, here, in front of him, the thing I have not let happen in front of another living person since I was eleven.

It doesn’t. Of course it doesn’t. I built the wall too well. I always build everything too well. That’s the whole problem, and it’s far too late to fix it now.

I stand up. My legs hold. I’m grateful for that much.

“I left the key on the counter,” I say. “And the hoodie. The grey one. I almost took it. I didn’t.”

“You could’ve taken the hoodie.” His voice is wrecked and low. It’s the only crack in him and he can’t even aim it where it would do damage. “Sloane. You could’ve taken the stupid hoodie.”