Page 18

“Sometimes it’s the man who comes home when he says he will. The man who pays attention to oil changes and insurance policies. The one who doesn’t make you wonder every day whether you’re safe.”

Safe.

There it was, the family scripture.

I wanted to reject it. I wanted to toss it back across the table and tell her safety wasn’t the same as happiness, that women weren’t meant to be tucked into respectable lives like tissue in gift boxes. But Paul’s older hand rose in my memory, resting on Ben’s shoulder in the emergency room. Paul reading hospital pamphlets with a yellow highlighter when Claire was hurt. Paul standing in the garage in winter, warming up my car before I drove to some committee meeting I hadn’t wanted to attend.

He had taken care of me, shown up, and that mattered, even if it wasn’t the whole of a life.

“Are you safe with Daddy?” I asked.

“Yes.”

The answer came too quickly.

“Are you happy?”

Her eyes held mine. For a moment, I didn’t see my mother as polished and certain and impossible to impress. I saw a younger woman in a yellow dress, laughing at some party near the lake, not yet Bitsy Hale in the permanent sense. Just Bitsy, before the rules finished settling around her.

“Happy isn’t a single thing,” she said.

I hated that because it sounded true.

She reached into the folder and removed a small photograph tucked beneath the guest list. I saw it only for a second before she seemed to remember herself. My parents stood by the lake before I was born, my father in a sport coat, my mother in a pale dress with her hair loosened by the wind. Beside them stood another man I didn’t recognize. Tall. Dark-haired. Laughing at something my mother must have said, because she was looking up at him with an expression I had never seen on her face.

“Who’s that?”

“No one.”

“Mom.”

She slid the photograph back beneath the papers. “A friend from a very long time ago.”

The way she said friend made it clear the word had been chosen for durability, not accuracy.

“What happened to him?”

“He wanted things your father didn’t.”

“What things?”

Her hand rested on the folder. “Freedom. Movement. A life that sounded exciting when I was twenty-one and exhausting when I imagined children in it.”

I stared at her.

My mother, who arranged flowers and corrected posture and knew exactly when to send thank-you notes, had once loved a man who made her think about freedom.

The thought moved through me with a strange tenderness. I had spent so many years making her the villain of my own story because she’d told me to be sensible, but maybe she’d only been passing down the map she’d used to get herself through.

“Do you ever wonder?” I asked.

She smoothed the top page. “Of course.”

That answer was worse than no.

Then she looked at me, and for once there wasn’t the usual briskness in her face.

“Wondering doesn’t raise children, doesn’t keep a house warm, or sit beside you when the doctor calls back. You think excitement will carry you because you’re young and your legs don’t hurt yet.”