Page 10 of Benjamin and the Thief

“I thought you said earlier that it’s very hard for you to stop once you get going,” she reminded him.

He chuckled. “Yeah, well, that’s right. But what I meant is that it would be very hard for me to stop making love to you, and there are many ways to make love, and not all of them mean that I have to be inside you. So if you feel uncomfortable once I’m inside you, please tell me, and we’ll try something else.”

She lifted her hand and caressed his cheek. “You’re an unusual man.”

“I hope that’s not a bad thing.”

She slid her hand onto his nape and pulled his face to hers. “It’s not. Not at all.”

She placed her other hand on his butt and drew him closer. “Now let me feel you inside me.”

Benjamin adjusted his cock and slowly pressed against her nether lips, parting them. Warmth and wetness greeted him as he submerged the tip of his cock inside Catalina’s pussy. Keeping eye contact, he went deeper, and her muscles clamped tightly around his shaft. Still, Catalina didn’t show any signs of discomfort. Instead, she now put both hands on his butt and forced him deeper, while at the same time, she spread her legs even farther and crossed her ankles below his butt.

His last inch slipped inside her, and he found himself seated in her enticing cave. A breath of air rushed from his lungs, while he remained motionless.

“You’re perfect,” she murmured.

He rejoiced in her words, relieved that despite the tight fit, she was able to accommodate his girth.

“Oh no, I’m not,” he whispered, “but you are, and that’s all that counts.”

He withdrew slowly, then drove back into her sheath. Her eyelids fluttered, and her lips parted, a soft breath tumbling over them. He’d never seen anything more enticing, more tempting than the petite woman in his arms welcoming his cock.

Again, he withdrew then plunged back inside her, this time faster than before.

“Oh, that’s good,” she claimed.

“You sure?”

“I’m sure.” She met his eyes. “I want you to take me how you like it best.”

“But I might be too rough.”

She shook her head. “You gave me what I needed earlier. Now I want to give you what you need.”

She had no idea what she was offering him. Already, he’d bitten her without her knowledge or consent, and now she wanted him to take her hard? He couldn’t. He’d been selfish enough.

“Alright,” he said, even though he had no intention of taking her up on her offer.

He freed himself from her embrace.

“What are you doing?” she asked.

“Taking you the way I want to.” He sat back on his heels. “Turn onto your side.”

She did as he asked, and he lay down behind her, her back against his chest, her ass fitting nicely into the curve of his groin.

He’d always loved this position, because it allowed him to cradle her while he fucked her from behind.

Gripping her thigh, he lifted it a little so he could slide his cock to her pussy. Without preamble, he thrust into her, while he held on to her hip to keep her close.

She moaned softly, and he nuzzled his face in the crook of her neck.

“Now be a good girl, and let me make love to you.”

As he began to thrust in and out of her, he kept his tempo slow, eager to make this last for as long as he could. It was another reason why he liked this position: he could do this for an hour and not get tired, and he could slow down his thrusts whenever he got too close to his orgasm. At the same time, he could caress the woman in his arms. At first, he lavished her breasts with pleasure, squeezing and caressing them, until she moaned uncontrollably, before he slid his hand to her clit.

While he thrust into her from behind, he rubbed over her clit in the same rhythm and tempo he’d done earlier. Every time he could feel her tense up—a sign that she was close to coming—he stopped and simply continued fucking her from behind. Then he caressed her clitoris again. He wasn’t sure how long he’d been doing this, but he knew that even his legendary stamina had to come to an end. When he felt Catalina close to her climax again, he didn’t stop touching her. It took only a few seconds more until her muscles spasmed, squeezing his cock in quick succession. He gasped at the intense pleasure of it and allowed himself to let go of the last vestiges of his control. His climax washed over him, drowning him in a sea of pleasure while he continued pumping his cock into Catalina’s pussy.