Page 61 of We Are Okay

“Keep the photographs, though. Okay?”

“Mm-hm,” he says.

I think of all of those pictures that Gramps kept for himself. My jaw clenches with the wrongness of it. He should have sat next to me and shown me. He should have said,Now, I think this was the time that... orOh yes, I remember this day...He should have told me all the ways in which I reminded him of her. He should have helped me remember her. He never should have let me forget.

Jones is still quiet. I hear his throat clearing.

“Your gramps, he was in a hospital a long time ago, when you stayed with us. Not sure if you remember. It almostkilled him, so we didn’t want to send him back there. Wish I could say that was the right decision. Wish I could say I didn’t realize it got so bad again.WishI could say that.”

I breathe in and out. It requires effort. “I thought he was sick.”

“Well, he was. Just in more ways than you thought.”

He clears his throat again. I wait.

“Sometimes it’s difficult,” he says, “to know the right thing to do.”

I nod even though he can’t see me. There’s no arguing with a statement like that, even if a different future is unfurling in my head—one where I knew what Gramps’s prescriptions were for, and I watched to make sure he took them, and he took me along to his appointments and his doctors told me what to watch for.

I need to find something kind to say, something instead of these thoughts of how Gramps failed me, how Jones failed us. He knows it already; I can hear it in his voice.

“Merry Christmas Eve, Jones,” I finally say, wanting the conversation to end.

“You get religious all of a sudden? If your gramps had a grave, he’d be turning in it.”

It’s a rough joke, the kind they used to make in my kitchen.

“It’s just something to say,” I tell him. Out the window, the snow is starting again. Not stormlike, just scatteredflakes drifting. “Give Agnes and Samantha my love, Jones. And tell the fellas I say hello.”

After I hang up, I cut open Hannah’s envelope and something flutters out. It unfolds in its descent: a paper chain of snowflakes, each one white and crisp. There is no message inside. It’s exactly what it appears to be.

chapter twenty-five

SEPTEMBER

I SHOWED UPon the day of freshman orientation, accompanied by no one, a duffel over my shoulder stuffed with my clothes, some crackers, and the picture of Birdie. I saw Hannah’s alarm when I appeared in our doorway. Then I saw her catch herself and smile.

She held out her hand, but her shock had taken me by the shoulders and shaken. I was here, at a school, surrounded by girls my own age. No one screamed at the television. No one stood for hours at their windows. No one avoided turning the tap for fear of ghosts.

I told myself,Pull it together.

I was a normal girl. I was not the kind to cause alarm. I was the kind who showered daily and wore clean clothes and answered the phone when it rang. When danger approached, I crossed the street. When mornings came, I ate breakfast.

This person who stood in the doorway wasn’t me.

I shook Hannah’s hand. I made my face smile.

“I must look like a disaster!” I said. “I’ve had a rough couple weeks. I’m going to set my stuff down and find the showers.”

Did I see relief pass over her? I hoped so. I went to unzip my duffel but thought of all the dirty clothes stuffed inside, of the smell they’d emit, and thought better.

“I’m going to find the laundry, too,” I said.

“Second floor,” Hannah told me. “And the bathrooms are right around the corner. We did the family tour this morning.”

I smiled again.

“Thanks,” I said.