Nikki Belgrave's It Would Have Been You is a captivating exploration of fate, family, and the self-imposed boundaries we create in our lives. At its core, the novel is a poignant examination of how fear can shape our existence, and the lengths to which one might go to reclaim a sense of agency. Through the lens of Drew Bailey's journey, Belgrave crafts a narrative that is both introspective and thrilling, set against the backdrop of a seemingly idyllic retreat that quickly becomes a crucible of tension and revelation.
The protagonist, Drew Bailey, is a character defined by her belief in a personal curse—a conviction that her presence brings misfortune to those she loves. This belief has led her to live a life of isolation, a "small life" as she describes it, where emotional connections are kept at arm's length. The novel's inciting incident, her brother's unexpected visit and ultimatum, serves as a catalyst for Drew's transformation. This setup is reminiscent of classic stories where a character is forced to confront their deepest fears, yet Belgrave adds a unique twist by intertwining the supernatural with the psychological.
Belgrave's choice of setting, Ravenwood Manor, is particularly inspired. The lavish reading retreat in Charlotte, North Carolina, is depicted with such vivid detail that it becomes a character in its own right. The manor's opulence and the promise of a weekend filled with luxury and leisure contrast sharply with the underlying tension that permeates the narrative. This juxtaposition is expertly handled, creating a sense of unease that builds as the story progresses.
The novel's themes are intricately woven into the plot. The idea of testing one's limits and the consequences of pushing against perceived boundaries are central to Drew's journey. As she adopts the persona of "Epic Drew," she embodies the courage to challenge her fears, albeit with trepidation. This transformation is both compelling and relatable, as many readers will recognize the struggle between self-imposed limitations and the desire for liberation.
Character development is one of Belgrave's strengths. Drew is a fully realized character, her internal conflict and growth depicted with nuance and empathy. Her interactions with the other guests at Ravenwood Manor, particularly the enigmatic stranger she finds herself drawn to, serve to highlight her evolving perspective. The supporting characters, while not as deeply explored, are nonetheless well-crafted, each adding a layer of complexity to the unfolding drama.
The narrative takes a dramatic turn when a storm traps the guests inside the manor, escalating the tension and forcing the characters to confront their own secrets and fears. This plot device is reminiscent of Agatha Christie's classic mysteries, where an isolated setting becomes the stage for unexpected revelations and tragedy. Belgrave handles this shift in tone with skill, maintaining a balance between suspense and introspection.
One of the novel's most striking elements is its exploration of luck and fate. The idea that "if you push your luck, luck will push back" serves as a cautionary tale, yet it also underscores the importance of agency and choice. Drew's journey is ultimately about reclaiming her narrative, challenging the notion that her life is dictated by forces beyond her control. This theme resonates deeply, offering readers a thought-provoking reflection on the power of belief and the courage to change one's path.
In comparison to other works in the genre, It Would Have Been You stands out for its blend of psychological depth and suspenseful storytelling. Fans of authors like Liane Moriarty and Ruth Ware will appreciate Belgrave's ability to weave complex characters into a gripping narrative. However, Belgrave's unique voice and the novel's supernatural undertones set it apart, offering a fresh take on familiar themes.
Overall, It Would Have Been You is a compelling read that combines elements of mystery, romance, and psychological drama. Nikki Belgrave has crafted a story that is both entertaining and thought-provoking, inviting readers to question the boundaries they set for themselves and the power of belief in shaping one's destiny. With its richly drawn characters and expertly paced plot, the novel is sure to leave a lasting impression on those who dare to explore the limits of luck and love.
